He claims: "China's the only government that's engaged in active, dynamic censorship. They're not shy about it"
He's right, they're not shy about it. But if you lived in China, should you care? Baidu is home-grown and controls roughly two-thirds of the Chinese search engine market. The government actively inconveniences itself to ensure Google remains relatively suppressed - all automated searches are from Baidu and has allegedly blocked Gmail in the past to prevent further access to the site. Naturally, the American head of the leading information search engine in the world, will push for looser internet censorship, but the question remains - WHY?
We can see the benefit from Google's point of view: increased market share which allows more to be charged for advertising, but what is the benefit for China? What's in it for them? They already have Baidu instead of Google, Sina Weibo instead of Twitter and RenRen instead of Facebook. These social media platforms are effective in ensuring the need for external networks remains diluted, but is this a good thing?
Firstly, one thing must be noted. China is currently wrestling with a paradox no other country truly experiences. It is an economic powerhouse, driving forwards whilst other nations stutter and stagger. But socially it is still developing. And that's putting it lightly. Accusations of human rights infringements and unjust individual freedom restrictions can be bandied about fairly. That argument can certainly be made. But for a country striving to dominate the world's marketplace, having such a controlled internet system is completely counter-productive. Internet in China is painfully slow and many webpages just don't even load, all because of the Firewall.
China has progressed economically at such a rapid rate but they run the risk of grinding to a halt if they don't allow at least a small increase in the flow of information. Other countries, in particular it's nearest competitor India, can increase innovative practices and R+D projects because of freer information flows. How does China expect to gauge global trends, new ideas and understand how people are living on a global scale if the have the most rigid internet restrictions in the world?
The World Wide Web, that envisaged and created by Tim Berners-Lee, was made for connections. Whilst the China Wide Web features inter-country connections, it isn't enough to compete in a world where globalisation is spreading faster than anyone can control it. It's an inevitability primarily brought on by internet-based developments. The Chinese can continue to fight for control, or give in to the era of Web 2.0, and experience the economic benefits it is truly capable of achieving.
Should Chinese citizens care? The answer is a resounding 'yes', not just from a social viewpoint, but an economic viewpoint as well. The ability to compete on a global level is diminished when a nation is afraid of what the internet will reveal and naturally their economic struggles will inevitably trickle down to an individual level. China wants to open itself up to trade and further economic development, but is this possible when they have the most restrictive web system in the world? The answer remains to be seen. I'd love to hear from my Chinese followers on this issue and gauge their thoughts on what's currently happen and what might happen.
